Last Updated on July 7, 2024 by Satish Mishra
Post covers When can Anticipatory Bail High Court Punjab Haryana be granted. Though it is entirely dependent on facts but the consideration criteria is laid out in the post which has remained successful amongst bail lawyers of High Court Chandigarh.
Though the judgment of one high court is not binding upon the other high court but is surely has the relevant consideration on law point. On that note this post just is an attempt to correlate the judgment of Allahabad High Court on topic of Anticipatory Bail which can also be opted by our High Court Chandigarh (Punjab & Haryana).
Anticipatory Bail High Court Punjab Haryana
Also Read- Apply for Bail but When and How?
It is a trite law that only in Special circumstances that ANTICIPATORY BAIL is maintainable before HC not in sessions court otherwise as per Section 438 of CrPC.
Now what are these special Circumstances, High Courts across the country have refrained from describing it so.
Recently HC Allahabad commented on Special Circumstances:
“ The court would be well advised to leave it to a judicious exercise of discretion in the facts of each case brought before it” Constitution Bench (Single Judge of Allahabad) in (Ankit Bharti & Ors. Vs. State of U.P. & Anr.)
Also Read- All About Getting Bail in India
So one can move to high court directly for grant of Anticipatory Bail, without moving the sessions Court but only in Special Circumstances which can never be reduced to writing, HC bench held.
Further Court Held – The court would clearly be look as in if attempting to draw a uniform code or dictum that may guide the exercise of discretion vested in the Court under Section 438 of the CrPC. The discretion wisely left unfettered by the legislature must be recognised as being available to be exercised defendant upon the facts & circumstances of each particular case.
The anticipatory bail application in Punjab and Haryana High Court must rest on a strong foundation in respect of apprehension of arrest as well as in justification of the concurrent jurisdiction of High Court being invoked directly.
Also Read- All About Getting Bail in Ndps Cases
In Onkar Nath Agarwal & Ors. Vs. Stare in 1976
3 – Judge bench already ruled High Court has concurrent jurisdiction to grant anticipatory bail
The 2nd part of code as per Sec 438 (CrPC) gives direction to release either on the order of HC or Court of session.
Also Read- Bail, Anticipatory Bail, Regular Bail, Interim Bail in Chandigarh
In Vinod Kumar Vs. State of U.P. & Anr., Judge Yashwant Varma ruled that ANTICIPATORY BAIL can be moved before HC if there are compelling and special circumstances if it justifies not to Anticipatory Bail approach sessions Court First.
It is left to Judge’s discretion to evaluate whether such special circumstances exist in a particular case or not.
Thus, in this backdrop, matter was referred to larger bench (Single Judge)
Before, Single Judge bench, the sole issues was of determining Special Circumstances.
Also Read- Apprehension of Arrest: Get an Anticipatory Bail.
Court denied the reference and upheld rightly not to define ‘Special Circumstances’ as in Vinod Kumar Case.
Single Judge Bench held – It would be imprudent to exhaustively chronicle what would constitute special circumstances.
Thus grounds of ANTICIPATORY BAIL before High Court Chandigarh can neither be placed in straight jacket nor can be comprehensively enumerated.
Also Read- Anticipatory Bail Basics
Even in Gurbaksh Singh Sibbia Vs. State of Punjab; the attempt of compendiously enumerate the myriad situations in which a petition for ANTICIPATORY BAIL may come to be moved was avoided.
In Sushila Aggarwal Vs. State (NCT of Delhi) ANTICIPATORY BAIL should only be dealt on concrete facts relatable to specific offences and not on vague or general allegations.
In the end, to conclude High Court held,
There can be no exhaustive or general exposition of circumstances in which an Anticipatory Bail applicant maybe held entitled to Anticipatory Bail approach the high Court directly
Thus, whether to Anticipatory Bail for ANTICIPATORY BAIL bail before sessions or Punjab Haryana High Court is a matter of facts and only the Top/Best/Expert Punjab Haryana High Court Lawyer advocate can suggest you the best legal recourse available.
Also Read- Anticipatory Bail in 498a Cases
To read relevant judgment on this, please browse this post on BarandBench.
For more information, dial 78883-35908