Uttirna Infraprojects Complaint -M3M City of Dreams

Haryana RERA Sets Aside Cancellation of Two Residential Plots Due to Invalid Possession Offer Without Completion Certificate. M3M City of Dreams II is a residential plotted colony project in Panipat developed by Uttirna Infraprojects Private Limited.

Uttirna Infraprojects Private Limited is the official promoter and developer of the M3M City of Dreams township project in Panipat, Haryana. Multiple formal complaints regarding this project have been filed and adjudicated before the Haryana Real Estate Regulatory Authority (HRERA), Panchkula. [1, 2, 3, 4].

To file a formal complaint regarding M3M City of Dreams (Panipat), submit your application to the Haryana Real Estate Regulatory Authority (HRERA), Panchkula, which holds jurisdiction over Panipat. The process requires both an online registration and a physical submission of documents.

Uttirna Infraprojects Complaint Panchkula RERA

In an important ruling concerning the legality of possession offers and cancellation of residential plot allotments, the Haryana Real Estate Regulatory Authority (HRERA), Panchkula, has held that a promoter cannot compel an allottee to accept possession on the basis of an offer issued without obtaining the requisite Completion Certificate or Part Completion Certificate from the competent authority.

In a common order dated 2 November 2026, the Authority disposed of two complaints, Complaint Nos. 1089 of 2025 and 1415 of 2025, concerning two residential plots in the project M3M City of Dreams II, Sector 36–39, District Panipat, Haryana.

The promoter had issued possession offers dated 6 February 2025 and subsequently cancelled the allotments on 21 June 2025, alleging non-payment of outstanding amounts by the allottees.

The central dispute was whether the promoter could treat the allottees as defaulters for not paying the demanded balance consideration when the possession offers themselves had been issued without the requisite statutory certification.

The Authority held that the possession offers dated 6 February 2025 were invalid because the promoter had not obtained the necessary Completion Certificate or Part Completion Certificate at the relevant time. It further held that the subsequent cancellation notices, which were founded upon the alleged failure to comply with those invalid offers, could not be sustained.

The Authority consequently directed restoration of both plots, required the promoter to obtain the necessary certification and issue fresh and valid possession offers, and directed execution of conveyance deeds within the prescribed period after actual handover.

Significantly, the Authority did not award delay interest at this stage because the contractual possession date of 30 September 2031 had not expired. The decision therefore distinguishes between an invalid premature possession offer and an actual delay in handing over possession attracting interest under Section 18 of the RERA Act.

Case Details

Particulars Details
Authority Haryana Real Estate Regulatory Authority, Panchkula
Date of Decision 2 November 2026
Member Nadim Akhtar
Complaint Nos. 1089 of 2025 and 1415 of 2025
Lead Complaint Complaint No. 1089 of 2025
Project M3M City of Dreams II
Project Location Sector 36–39, District Panipat, Haryana
Promoter Uttirna Infraprojects Private Limited
Plot in Complaint No. 1089 D-01/22
Plot in Complaint No. 1415 D-01/21
Area of Each Plot 239.20 square yards
Allotment Date 20 February 2024
Builder-Buyer Agreement 5 April 2024
Contractual Possession Date 30 September 2031
Possession Offer Date 6 February 2025
Cancellation Date 21 June 2025

Background of the Two Complaints

Both complaints arose from allotments made in the same real estate project, developed by the same promoter.

The Authority treated Complaint No. 1089 of 2025 as the lead case because the principal legal issues in both complaints were similar.

The dispute concerned two residential plots:

  • Plot No. D-01/22 in Complaint No. 1089 of 2025.
  • Plot No. D-01/21 in Complaint No. 1415 of 2025.

Each plot measured 239.20 square yards.

The allotment letters were issued on 20 February 2024, and the Builder-Buyer Agreements were executed on 5 April 2024.

The total sale consideration for each plot was ₹1,93,99,280, apart from applicable charges.

The complainants had made substantial payments towards the agreed consideration. The order records a payment of ₹57,74,384 in Complaint No. 1089 of 2025. The payment particulars for the second complaint are separately reflected in the case record.

The possession offer dated 6 February 2025

The promoter issued possession offer letters dated 6 February 2025, calling upon the allottees to pay the balance amounts and take possession of their respective plots.

The complainants questioned the validity of these offers.

They contended that the promoter had not provided the Completion Certificate or Occupation Certificate and that the project was not legally ready for possession.

They also alleged that the construction progress reflected in the quarterly project updates and the photographs and videos of the site contradicted the promoter’s claim that the project was complete.

The complainants repeatedly requested the promoter to provide the Completion Certificate and other statutory documents.

Cancellation of allotments

Instead of providing the requested statutory certification, the promoter issued pre-cancellation notices in March 2025 and subsequently issued cancellation notices dated 21 June 2025.

The promoter alleged that the allottees had failed to pay the outstanding amounts despite repeated reminders and opportunities.

The complainants challenged the cancellation, contending that they could not be treated as defaulters for failing to comply with an offer of possession that was itself legally invalid.

They also questioned the promoter’s subsequent refund and the purported creation of third-party rights in respect of the plots.

Reliefs Sought by the Complainants

The complainants sought various directions from Haryana RERA, including:

  1. Declaration that the possession offers dated 6 February 2025 were null, void, illegal and premature.
  2. Setting aside the cancellation notices dated 21 June 2025.
  3. Restoration of the original allotments with all consequential rights.
  4. Alternatively, allotment of plots of equivalent value and price in the same project.
  5. Restraining the promoter from creating third-party rights during the pendency of the proceedings.
  6. Direction to issue valid possession offers only after obtaining the requisite Completion Certificate and Occupation Certificate, as applicable.
  7. Grant of interest for the period of delay in offering lawful possession.
  8. Reimbursement of alleged litigation expenses.
  9. Appropriate action for alleged violations of statutory obligations under the RERA Act.

The complainants also raised concerns regarding project approvals, statutory permissions, construction progress and the availability of essential services.

Defence Raised by the Promoter

The promoter contested the complaints and relied upon the terms of the Builder-Buyer Agreements.

Its principal submissions were as follows:

1. The payment plan was time-linked, not construction-linked

The promoter argued that the complainants had opted for a time-linked payment plan.

According to the promoter, the complainants were required to make payments within the stipulated contractual timelines, irrespective of the construction status of the individual plots or the project.

It therefore contended that the allottees had committed repeated defaults by failing to pay the outstanding instalments.

2. Possession had been validly offered

The promoter submitted that possession had been offered on 6 February 2025 in accordance with Clause 7.2(A) of the Builder-Buyer Agreement and the Haryana RERA Rules.

It argued that the relevant provision permitted possession upon obtaining either the approved demarcation-cum-zoning plan or a Completion Certificate, as applicable.

According to the promoter, the zoning plan had been approved and the essential infrastructure and services had been provided.

3. Completion Certificate was not a precondition to possession

The promoter relied upon the wording of Clause 7.2(A) of the Model Agreement under the Haryana RERA Rules, 2017.

It argued that the use of the expression “OR” meant that possession could be offered upon approval of the demarcation-cum-zoning plan or upon obtaining a Completion Certificate.

It further relied upon communications issued by the Department of Town and Country Planning, Haryana, to support its interpretation.

4. The allotments were cancelled due to persistent payment defaults

The promoter contended that repeated reminders, pre-cancellation notices and a final opportunity had been given to the complainants.

It submitted that the complainants failed to pay the outstanding dues and that the cancellation notices were therefore issued in accordance with the Builder-Buyer Agreements.

5. Refund and creation of third-party rights

The promoter stated that an amount of ₹37,76,905 had been refunded to the complainant in Complaint No. 1089 of 2025 on 8 July 2025.

It further contended that, following cancellation, third-party rights had been created in favour of another entity in respect of the disputed plot.

According to the promoter, the complainants’ claims had consequently become infructuous.

Issue for Adjudication

The Authority identified the principal issue as:

Whether the complainants were entitled to the reliefs claimed under the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016?

The principal legal question was whether the possession offers dated 6 February 2025 were valid despite the absence of the requisite Completion Certificate or Part Completion Certificate at the time of their issuance, and whether the subsequent cancellations based on alleged non-payment could consequently be sustained.

Findings and Legal Reasoning of Haryana RERA

1. Statutory obligation of the promoter to obtain Completion Certificate or Occupation Certificate

The Authority examined Section 11(4)(b) of the RERA Act, 2016.

This provision places an obligation upon the promoter to obtain the Completion Certificate or Occupation Certificate, as applicable, from the competent authority in accordance with local laws and to make it available to the allottees.

The Authority emphasised that the statutory obligation to obtain the necessary certificate rests upon the promoter.

It cannot be shifted to the allottee or treated as an optional contractual requirement.

The Authority observed that the promoter’s obligation under the RERA Act must be fulfilled before a legally valid offer of possession can be made.

2. Completion of construction work is different from statutory certification

One of the most significant observations in the order concerns the distinction between physical completion of development work and certification by the competent authority.

The promoter argued that the internal roads, services, infrastructure and other essential facilities had been completed.

It also relied upon the approval of the zoning plan and the availability of services at the site.

The Authority, however, held that the promoter’s own satisfaction regarding completion of development work cannot substitute the statutory certification required under the applicable regulatory framework.

It explained that the following are distinct stages:

  • Execution of development work by the promoter.
  • Approval of plans.
  • Provision of services and infrastructure.
  • Certification by the competent authority that the development has reached the legally prescribed stage.

The Authority held that approval of a plan or completion of internal development work does not automatically establish compliance with the statutory requirements governing lawful possession.

The promoter cannot substitute its own assessment of completion for the statutory certification of the competent authority.

3. Interpretation of Rule 7.2(A) of the Haryana RERA Rules, 2017

The promoter relied upon Rule 7.2(A) of the Haryana Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Rules, 2017.

It argued that the use of the expression “OR” in the provision permitted possession upon obtaining either an approved demarcation-cum-zoning plan or a Completion Certificate.

The Authority rejected the promoter’s interpretation.

It observed that a statutory provision must be read as a whole, keeping in view its object, purpose and the statutory protection intended to be provided to the allottee.

The expression “as the case may be” could not be interpreted as creating an absolute exemption from obtaining a Completion Certificate wherever such certification was required under the applicable law.

The Authority held that the promoter could not rely upon one word or punctuation mark in isolation to defeat the statutory requirements.

It further observed that an allottee who is called upon to take possession is entitled to know that the development forming part of the colony has been examined and certified by the competent authority to the extent required by law.

4. Administrative communication cannot override statutory requirements

The promoter relied upon a memorandum issued by the Department of Town and Country Planning, Haryana, concerning the stage at which conveyance deeds could be executed in respect of plots.

The Authority held that an administrative communication cannot override the substantive statutory requirements governing the development and lawful possession of plots.

It observed that the subject matter of execution or registration of conveyance deeds cannot, by itself, displace the statutory requirements relating to completion of development work and lawful possession.

The Authority also noted that the RERA Act was already in force when the administrative memorandum was issued.

Accordingly, the memorandum had to be interpreted harmoniously with the provisions of the RERA Act and the rules framed thereunder.

5. Possession offer dated 6 February 2025 was invalid

The Authority examined the documents and statutory approvals available on the date of the possession offer.

It found that the promoter had issued the possession offer dated 6 February 2025 without obtaining the requisite Completion Certificate or Part Completion Certificate from the competent authority.

The Authority specifically held that the possession offer could not be treated as valid merely because the promoter claimed that the plot was ready or that the essential services were available.

It further held that the subsequent procurement of a Completion Certificate on 16 October 2026 did not retrospectively validate the earlier possession offer.

The legality of a possession offer must be examined with reference to the statutory approvals and documents available on the date on which the offer was made.

A certificate obtained later cannot cure an offer that was legally invalid when issued.

6. Allottees could not be treated as defaulters for refusing an invalid possession offer

The promoter argued that the complainants had failed to pay the outstanding instalments despite repeated reminders.

The Authority examined this defence in light of the invalidity of the possession offers.

It observed that the promoter could not demand payment by relying upon an offer of possession that did not satisfy the statutory requirements.

The Authority held that the promoter was required to first place itself in a position to lawfully offer possession and thereafter call upon the allottees to perform their corresponding contractual obligations.

The complainants could not be treated as defaulters merely because they did not accept an invalid or premature possession offer.

7. Cancellation notices dated 21 June 2025 were unsustainable

The Authority examined the sequence of events leading to cancellation.

The cancellation notices were based upon the alleged failure of the complainants to comply with the possession offers and payment demands.

However, the foundational possession offers had already been found to be invalid.

The Authority held that an action founded upon an invalid or legally unsustainable offer could not acquire independent validity merely because it was taken subsequently.

It observed that the promoter could not derive a benefit from its own failure to obtain the requisite statutory certification before issuing the possession offers.

Consequently, the cancellation notices dated 21 June 2025 were held to be invalid and were set aside.

8. Subsequent refund did not extinguish the complainants’ rights

The promoter relied upon the refund of ₹37,76,905 made on 8 July 2025 in Complaint No. 1089 of 2025.

The Authority rejected the argument that the refund had made the complaint infructuous.

It held that the refund was a consequential step arising from the cancellation of the allotment.

Where the cancellation itself was legally unsustainable, the subsequent refund could not independently validate the cancellation or extinguish the allottee’s rights.

The Authority therefore held that the refund did not deprive the complainant of the right to seek restoration of the original allotment.

9. Purported third-party rights did not defeat restoration of the original allotment

The promoter also argued that third-party rights had been created in respect of the disputed plot.

The Authority examined the material relating to the subsequent allotment made in favour of M/s KWH Estate.

It noted that the promoter had not produced an executed conveyance deed or sufficient documentary evidence establishing the creation of an enforceable legal title in favour of the subsequent allottee.

The Authority further noted that the subsequent entity had paid only 10% of the total sale consideration.

Relying upon the legal principles concerning transfer of title in immovable property, the Authority held that a mere Builder-Buyer Agreement or allotment letter does not, by itself, create legal title or an indefeasible interest in immovable property.

The Authority referred to the Supreme Court decision in Suraj Lamp and Industries Pvt. Ltd. v. State of Haryana (2012) 1 SCC 656 and the principles reiterated in Indian Overseas Bank v. M.A.S. Subramanian (2025).

It held that the purported third-party rights could not be recognised as a justification for sustaining an otherwise invalid cancellation.

The Authority therefore set aside the purported rights claimed to have been created in favour of the subsequent allottee on the material before it.

10. Delay interest under Section 18 was not presently payable

An important aspect of the decision is the Authority’s treatment of the claim for delay interest.

The complainants sought interest on account of delay in offering lawful possession.

The Authority examined Clause 7.1(ii) of the Builder-Buyer Agreement.

The contractual possession date was 30 September 2031, subject to the terms and conditions of the agreement and permissible extensions.

The Authority observed that Section 18(1) of the RERA Act provides consequences where the promoter fails to complete or is unable to give possession in accordance with the agreement for sale by the specified date.

It held that the liability to pay interest for delay is attracted upon actual failure to hand over possession within the agreed or legally applicable period.

Since the contractual possession date had not yet expired, the Authority held that the claim for delay interest was premature and could not be granted at that stage.

It clarified that a mere apprehension of future delay does not, by itself, create an existing default under Section 18.

This finding is particularly important because it distinguishes an invalid possession offer from a claim for delay interest arising after the agreed possession deadline.

11. Compensation and litigation expenses to be considered by the Adjudicating Officer

The complainants also sought litigation expenses and compensation for alleged harassment, inconvenience and hardship.

The Authority referred to the Supreme Court decision in Newtech Promoters and Developers Pvt. Ltd. v. State of Uttar Pradesh, Civil Appeal Nos. 6745–6749 of 2021.

It observed that claims for compensation and litigation expenses under the relevant provisions of the RERA Act are to be adjudicated by the competent Adjudicating Officer.

The complainants were accordingly advised to approach the Adjudicating Officer for the appropriate relief.

Final Directions Issued by Haryana RERA

After considering the pleadings, documents and statutory provisions, the Authority issued the following directions under Section 37 of the RERA Act:

1. Restoration of both plots

The promoter was directed to restore the allotments of the following plots with immediate effect:

  • Plot No. D-01/22 measuring 239.20 square yards in Complaint No. 1089 of 2025.
  • Plot No. D-01/21 measuring 239.20 square yards in Complaint No. 1415 of 2025.

Both plots are situated in the project M3M City of Dreams II, Sector 36–39, District Panipat, Haryana.

2. Obtain the requisite Completion Certificate or Part Completion Certificate

The promoter was directed to comply with its statutory obligation under Section 11(4)(b) of the RERA Act by obtaining the requisite Completion Certificate or Part Completion Certificate, as applicable, from the competent authority.

The certificate must be made available to the allottees.

3. Issue fresh and valid possession offers

After obtaining the requisite statutory certification, the promoter was directed to issue fresh and valid possession offers to the complainants in accordance with the RERA Act and applicable rules.

4. Payment of balance sale consideration

The complainants were directed to pay the amounts legally due under their respective Builder-Buyer Agreements.

The promoter was restrained from charging any amount over and above the amounts already agreed upon under the Builder-Buyer Agreements.

5. Execution of conveyance deeds

The promoter was directed to execute the conveyance deeds in respect of the complainants’ plots within 90 days of actual handover of possession of the respective units.

6. Interest rate applicable in case of default

The Authority directed that the interest rate chargeable from the allottees in case of default would be the prescribed rate of 10.95%, which was also the rate at which the promoter would be liable to pay interest to the allottees.

7. Compliance period

The promoter was granted 90 days to comply with the directions contained in the order, as provided under Rule 16 of the Haryana RERA Rules, 2017.

The Authority further observed that failure to comply could invite legal consequences.

Important Legal Principles Emerging from the Decision

The order lays down several important principles relevant to disputes concerning residential plots and possession offers under the RERA Act.

1. A possession offer must comply with statutory requirements

A promoter cannot make a legally valid possession offer merely by asserting that the plot or project is ready.

Where a Completion Certificate or Part Completion Certificate is required under the applicable regulatory framework, obtaining that certification is a statutory obligation.

2. Physical readiness is not equivalent to statutory completion

The completion of roads, infrastructure, internal services and other development works does not automatically establish that the project has reached the stage legally required for possession.

Certification by the competent authority is a separate and important requirement.

3. Subsequent certification does not retrospectively validate an earlier invalid offer

The legality of a possession offer must be examined with reference to the statutory approvals available on the date of issuance.

A Completion Certificate obtained subsequently cannot retrospectively cure an offer that was invalid when made.

4. A promoter cannot rely upon an invalid offer to cancel an allotment

If the possession offer is legally invalid, the promoter cannot treat the allottee’s failure to comply with that offer as a valid contractual default and use it as the foundation for cancellation.

5. Refund following an invalid cancellation does not automatically extinguish allotment rights

A refund made as a consequence of an invalid cancellation does not independently validate the cancellation or necessarily extinguish the allottee’s right to seek restoration.

6. Third-party allotment does not automatically create legal title

An allotment letter or Builder-Buyer Agreement, without the necessary conveyance and supporting legal requirements, does not by itself establish an indefeasible title in immovable property.

7. Delay interest depends upon the contractual possession deadline

An invalid possession offer does not automatically mean that delay interest under Section 18 is immediately payable.

The Authority must examine the agreed possession date and determine whether the promoter has actually failed to deliver possession within the prescribed period.

In the present case, the contractual date of 30 September 2031 had not expired, and the claim for delay interest was therefore held to be premature.

Practical Lessons for Homebuyers

This decision offers important guidance to homebuyers purchasing residential plots in licensed colonies.

  • Always examine whether the promoter has obtained the requisite Completion Certificate or Part Completion Certificate before accepting possession.
  • Do not assume that approval of a zoning plan or availability of infrastructure automatically establishes legal completion.
  • Preserve possession offers, demand letters, cancellation notices and correspondence seeking statutory documents.
  • Verify the exact contractual possession date and applicable grace period.
  • If a promoter demands payment on the basis of a possession offer, examine whether the offer complies with the RERA Act and applicable rules.
  • Challenge cancellation where it is founded upon non-compliance with an invalid possession offer.
  • Preserve bank statements, receipts and proof of payments made towards the sale consideration.
  • If the promoter claims to have created third-party rights, examine whether any valid conveyance deed or other legally enforceable transfer has actually taken place.
  • Understand the distinction between restoration of allotment and entitlement to delay interest. The latter depends upon the applicable contractual deadline and statutory requirements.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Q1. What did Haryana RERA decide in Complaint Nos. 1089 and 1415 of 2025?

Haryana RERA set aside the cancellation of two residential plot allotments in M3M City of Dreams II, Panipat. It held that the possession offers dated 6 February 2025 were invalid because the requisite Completion Certificate or Part Completion Certificate had not been obtained at the relevant time.

Q2. Can a promoter offer possession without a Completion Certificate?

Where a Completion Certificate or Part Completion Certificate is required under the applicable statutory framework, the promoter must obtain it before making a legally valid offer of possession. The promoter’s own assertion that construction is complete cannot substitute the required statutory certification.

Q3. Can a promoter cancel an allotment if the buyer does not pay after receiving an invalid possession offer?

According to this order, a promoter cannot rely upon an invalid possession offer as the foundation for cancellation on the ground that the allottee failed to make the demanded payment or take possession.

Q4. Does a Completion Certificate obtained later validate an earlier possession offer?

No. Haryana RERA held that the validity of a possession offer must be examined with reference to the documents and statutory approvals available on the date the offer was made. A certificate obtained subsequently does not retrospectively validate an earlier invalid offer.

Q5. Does refund of the amount after cancellation make the RERA complaint infructuous?

Not automatically. Where the cancellation itself is found to be legally unsustainable, a subsequent refund made as a consequence of that cancellation cannot independently validate the cancellation or extinguish the allottee’s rights.

Q6. Can a subsequent allotment create third-party rights in a plot whose original cancellation is invalid?

The Authority examined the purported subsequent allotment and found insufficient evidence of an enforceable legal title, particularly in the absence of an executed conveyance deed. It held that the purported third-party rights could not justify sustaining the invalid cancellation.

Q7. Why was delay interest not awarded in this case?

The Builder-Buyer Agreements specified 30 September 2031 as the contractual possession date. Since that date had not expired, the Authority held that the claim for delay interest under Section 18 was premature.

Q8. What relief was granted to the complainants?

The Authority directed restoration of both plots, obtaining the requisite Completion Certificate or Part Completion Certificate, issuing fresh and valid possession offers, accepting payment of contractual dues and executing conveyance deeds within 90 days of actual handover.

Q9. What is the interest rate prescribed in the final directions?

The Authority specified an interest rate of 10.95% for defaults by the allottees, being the same prescribed rate at which the promoter would be liable to pay interest to the allottees.

Q10. Within what period must the promoter execute the conveyance deed?

The promoter was directed to execute the conveyance deed within 90 days of actual handover of possession of the respective plot.

Conclusion

The common order passed by Haryana RERA, Panchkula, in Complaint Nos. 1089 and 1415 of 2025 reinforces the statutory responsibility of a real estate promoter to ensure that possession is offered only after satisfying the applicable legal and regulatory requirements.

The Authority made it clear that physical completion of development work, approval of a zoning plan or the availability of essential services cannot automatically replace statutory certification by the competent authority.

It further held that an allottee cannot be treated as a defaulter for refusing to comply with an invalid possession offer and that a subsequent cancellation based upon such an offer cannot be sustained.

By restoring both residential plots and directing the promoter to obtain the requisite certification before issuing fresh possession offers, the Authority reaffirmed the importance of statutory compliance and protection of allottee rights under the RERA Act.

At the same time, the decision clarifies that an invalid possession offer and a claim for delay interest are legally distinct matters. Since the agreed possession date of 30 September 2031 had not expired, the Authority declined to award delay interest at this stage.

The ruling is particularly relevant to disputes involving premature possession offers, absence of Completion Certificates, cancellation for alleged payment defaults and subsequent creation of purported third-party rights.

Case Reference: Common Order in Complaint Nos. 1089 of 2025 and 1415 of 2025, Haryana Real Estate Regulatory Authority, Panchkula, decided on 2 November 2026.

Disclaimer: This article is intended for general legal information and educational purposes only. It is based on the order referred to above and should not be treated as legal advice. The outcome of any other matter will depend on its individual facts, contractual documents and applicable law.

More on 99888-17966

Leave a Comment

Call Us